pepperoni pizza

Total Time24 hrs
DifficultyChallenging
SimpleNo real technique needed. Follow the steps and you'll be fine.
StraightforwardEasy going but worth paying attention. A good one to build confidence.
Building SkillsYou'll learn something making this. Great for developing technique.
Technique RequiredYou need to know what you're doing. Read the method before you start.
ChallengingThis will push you. Worth every bit of effort.
AdvancedSerious cooking. Rewarding when it comes together.
Servings4

This is pizza the way a proper pizza oven makes it — a long, cold ferment for real depth of flavour, a stretch-and-launch method that takes practice, and a 90-second blast of fierce heat that a normal oven simply can't produce. Low moisture mozzarella for structure, a little fresh mozzarella for pull, and a genuinely good pepperoni that crisps at the edges rather than just sitting there.

This is a Pro feature

Get the full Cooked Properly experience for £3.99/mo

  • 🗓️ Plan your week and build your shopping list in two taps
  • ⚖️ Scale any recipe to exactly the servings you need
  • 💡 Unlock Why This Works and Common Failures on every recipe
  • 🔖 Save unlimited recipes
See All Pro Features →

Save this recipe for later

Free to join — no card required

  • 🔖 Save up to 10 recipes for free, access them anytime
  • 🗓️ Upgrade to Pro to plan your week and sort your shop in two taps
  • ⚖️ Scale recipes to exactly the servings you need with Pro
Create a free account

Ingredients

Servings: 4
  • For the dough
  • 500 g Caputo Pizzeria 00 flour
  • 300 g Water, lukewarm
  • 15 g Fine sea salt
  • 0.5 g Instant yeast
  • 200 g Fine semolina, for opening and launching the dough
  • For the sauce
  • 400 g Tinned plum tomatoes
  • 50 g Tomato purée
  • 6 g Fine sea salt
  • For the toppings
  • 300 g Low moisture mozzarella, grated, or cut into small squares
  • 100 g Fresh mozzarella, torn and drained
  • 120 g Pepperoni, see notes
  • To serve
  • 50 g Parmesan, finely grated
  • 50 g Hot honey, see notes

Scale this recipe with Pro

Cooking for two or feeding a crowd — every ingredient adjusts instantly

  • ⚖️ Scale any recipe to exactly the servings you need
  • 🗓️ Plan your week and build your shopping list in two taps
  • ⭐ Unlock Pro Tips and Why This Works on select steps
See All Pro Features →

Your shopping list, sorted

Plan your week and create your entire shop in two taps

  • 🛒 Add this recipe to your shopping list instantly
  • 🗓️ Plan a full week of meals and generate one combined shopping list
  • ✓ Duplicate ingredients combine automatically — no double-buying
See All Pro Features →

Equipment

  • High temperature pizza oven
  • Pizza peel
  • Turning peel
  • Pizza cutter
  • Dough tray or plastic bowl

Method

Mix the dough
1

Put the lukewarm water in a large bowl and add the instant yeast, stirring until dissolved. Add half the flour and stir into a rough mix, then add the remaining flour and mix until roughly combined. Add the salt and mix again.

Ingredients for this step:

  • 500 g Caputo Pizzeria 00 flour
  • 300 g Water, lukewarm
  • 15 g Fine sea salt
  • 0.5 g Instant yeast
Knead the dough
2

Turn the dough out onto a clean worksurface and knead for 10 minutes, until smooth and elastic. If you haven’t kneaded dough before, a short video demonstration will show the motion far more clearly than text can — look one up before starting if this is new to you.

Rest and shape into a ball
3

Cover the dough with a towel and leave to rest for 10 minutes. Once rested, shape it into a tight ball: fold the edges of the dough into the centre, then turn it over so the seam is underneath, and use the sides of your hands to drag the dough in a circular motion against the worksurface, building surface tension across the top as you go. The ball should feel firm and springy, with a smooth, unbroken surface.

This is easier to see than to read — a short video of the technique will make the motion much clearer than a written description.

Bulk ferment overnight
4

Place the shaped dough in an oiled plastic bowl or dough tray, cover, and leave to bulk ferment overnight.

Divide and shape the dough balls
5

The next morning, divide the dough into 4 even 200g pieces and shape each into a tight ball using the same method as before. Place spaced out in a dough tray with the lid on, or on a tray covered with clingfilm.

Leave to proof for 8 hours, ideally somewhere around 18–20°C. On a very hot day, keep them somewhere cool; on a very cold day, keep them somewhere warmer.

Preheat the oven and prep the toppings
6

30 minutes before cooking, begin preheating the pizza oven on a high flame. See how to use a pizza oven for guidance on getting it up to temperature.

While it heats, blend the tinned tomatoes, tomato purée, and salt until smooth and pour into a bowl with a ladle. Grate the low moisture mozzarella and tear the fresh mozzarella, placing the fresh mozzarella on kitchen paper to drain off as much moisture as possible. Prepare a bowl of semolina for opening the dough.

Ingredients for this step:

  • 400 g Tinned plum tomatoes
  • 50 g Tomato purée
  • 6 g Fine sea salt
  • 300 g Low moisture mozzarella, grated, or cut into small squares
  • 100 g Fresh mozzarella, torn and drained
Open and top the dough
7

Once the pizza oven reads around 450°C (842°F) on the stone, dip a dough ball in the semolina and stretch it out on a semolina-dusted worksurface. Work from the centre outward, pressing with your fingertips to push air to the edges and leave a puffy rim, then gently stretch and open up the disc larger on the back of your hands. The finished base should have stretched to around 12 inch diameter. A video demonstration is worth far more than a written description for this step — watch a few before your first attempt.

Add a ladle of tomato sauce and spread it out, leaving a border of around 2cm of unsauced crust. Sprinkle over 75g of the low moisture mozzarella and a few chunks of the fresh mozzarella, keeping enough in reserve for the remaining pizzas. Cover generously with pepperoni.

Ingredients for this step:

  • 200 g Fine semolina, for opening and launching the dough
  • 120 g Pepperoni, see notes
Launch and cook the pizza
8

Slide the topped dough onto a semolina-dusted peel and stretch it out slightly to reach the edges, rearranging any toppings quickly if needed. Work fast here — the dough will start to stick to the peel the longer it sits.

Lower the flame to medium-low and launch the pizza into the oven. Turn using the turning peel once the side nearest the flame begins to form leopard spots, rotating 180 degrees and letting the opposite side colour to match. Continue turning until the whole pizza is cooked to your liking — the full cook takes around 60–90 seconds. You’ll likely know your own oven’s habits better than any written guide, so adjust to how yours behaves.

Finish and serve
9

Remove the pizza from the oven and sprinkle over the Parmesan. Drizzle with hot honey if using. Slice and serve immediately while hot.

Repeat for the remaining dough balls — and remember, the chef always eats last.

Ingredients for this step:

  • 50 g Parmesan, finely grated
  • 50 g Hot honey, see notes

Notes & Substitutions

You need a genuine high-temperature pizza oven for this recipe. A stone reaching 450°C (842°F) or higher and an open rolling flame produce a rise, char, and texture that a standard domestic oven cannot reproduce. This recipe is written specifically for a high-temperature pizza oven such as a Gozney Roccbox or similar — attempting it in a conventional oven will not give the same result.

Low moisture mozzarella: pre-sliced squares of mozzarella from the supermarket are a good substitute in the UK, where blocks can be harder to find. Cut into small squares instead of grating — the result is just as good.

Pepperoni: a good quality pepperoni such as Properoni brand will crisp up at the edges in the oven rather than turning greasy and limp.

Hot honey: see the hot honey recipe for how to make your own.

Pepperoni Pizza

Total time: 24 hrs  •  Difficulty: Challenging  •  Servings: 4

This is pizza the way a proper pizza oven makes it — a long, cold ferment for real depth of flavour, a stretch-and-launch method that takes practice, and a 90-second blast of fierce heat that a normal oven simply can't produce. Low moisture mozzarella for structure, a little fresh mozzarella for pull, and a genuinely good pepperoni that crisps at the edges rather than just sitting there.

Ingredients

  • 500 g Caputo Pizzeria 00 flour
  • 300 g Water (lukewarm)
  • 15 g Fine sea salt
  • 0.5 g Instant yeast
  • 200 g Fine semolina (for opening and launching the dough)
  • 400 g Tinned plum tomatoes
  • 50 g Tomato purée
  • 6 g Fine sea salt
  • 300 g Low moisture mozzarella (grated, or cut into small squares)
  • 100 g Fresh mozzarella (torn and drained)
  • 120 g Pepperoni (see notes)
  • 50 g Parmesan (finely grated)
  • 50 g Hot honey (see notes)

Equipment

  • High temperature pizza oven
  • Pizza peel
  • Turning peel
  • Pizza cutter
  • Dough tray or plastic bowl

Method

Mix the dough

1.

Put the lukewarm water in a large bowl and add the instant yeast, stirring until dissolved. Add half the flour and stir into a rough mix, then add the remaining flour and mix until roughly combined. Add the salt and mix again.

For this step: 500 g Caputo Pizzeria 00 flour, 300 g Water, 15 g Fine sea salt, 0.5 g Instant yeast

Knead the dough

2.

Turn the dough out onto a clean worksurface and knead for 10 minutes, until smooth and elastic. If you haven’t kneaded dough before, a short video demonstration will show the motion far more clearly than text can — look one up before starting if this is new to you.

Rest and shape into a ball

3.

Cover the dough with a towel and leave to rest for 10 minutes. Once rested, shape it into a tight ball: fold the edges of the dough into the centre, then turn it over so the seam is underneath, and use the sides of your hands to drag the dough in a circular motion against the worksurface, building surface tension across the top as you go. The ball should feel firm and springy, with a smooth, unbroken surface.

This is easier to see than to read — a short video of the technique will make the motion much clearer than a written description.

Bulk ferment overnight

4.

Place the shaped dough in an oiled plastic bowl or dough tray, cover, and leave to bulk ferment overnight.

Divide and shape the dough balls

5.

The next morning, divide the dough into 4 even 200g pieces and shape each into a tight ball using the same method as before. Place spaced out in a dough tray with the lid on, or on a tray covered with clingfilm.

Leave to proof for 8 hours, ideally somewhere around 18–20°C. On a very hot day, keep them somewhere cool; on a very cold day, keep them somewhere warmer.

Preheat the oven and prep the toppings

6.

30 minutes before cooking, begin preheating the pizza oven on a high flame. See how to use a pizza oven for guidance on getting it up to temperature.

While it heats, blend the tinned tomatoes, tomato purée, and salt until smooth and pour into a bowl with a ladle. Grate the low moisture mozzarella and tear the fresh mozzarella, placing the fresh mozzarella on kitchen paper to drain off as much moisture as possible. Prepare a bowl of semolina for opening the dough.

For this step: 400 g Tinned plum tomatoes, 50 g Tomato purée, 6 g Fine sea salt, 300 g Low moisture mozzarella, 100 g Fresh mozzarella

Open and top the dough

7.

Once the pizza oven reads around 450°C (842°F) on the stone, dip a dough ball in the semolina and stretch it out on a semolina-dusted worksurface. Work from the centre outward, pressing with your fingertips to push air to the edges and leave a puffy rim, then gently stretch and open up the disc larger on the back of your hands. The finished base should have stretched to around 12 inch diameter. A video demonstration is worth far more than a written description for this step — watch a few before your first attempt.

Add a ladle of tomato sauce and spread it out, leaving a border of around 2cm of unsauced crust. Sprinkle over 75g of the low moisture mozzarella and a few chunks of the fresh mozzarella, keeping enough in reserve for the remaining pizzas. Cover generously with pepperoni.

For this step: 200 g Fine semolina, 120 g Pepperoni

Launch and cook the pizza

8.

Slide the topped dough onto a semolina-dusted peel and stretch it out slightly to reach the edges, rearranging any toppings quickly if needed. Work fast here — the dough will start to stick to the peel the longer it sits.

Lower the flame to medium-low and launch the pizza into the oven. Turn using the turning peel once the side nearest the flame begins to form leopard spots, rotating 180 degrees and letting the opposite side colour to match. Continue turning until the whole pizza is cooked to your liking — the full cook takes around 60–90 seconds. You’ll likely know your own oven’s habits better than any written guide, so adjust to how yours behaves.

Finish and serve

9.

Remove the pizza from the oven and sprinkle over the Parmesan. Drizzle with hot honey if using. Slice and serve immediately while hot.

Repeat for the remaining dough balls — and remember, the chef always eats last.

For this step: 50 g Parmesan, 50 g Hot honey

Notes & Substitutions

You need a genuine high-temperature pizza oven for this recipe. A stone reaching 450°C (842°F) or higher and an open rolling flame produce a rise, char, and texture that a standard domestic oven cannot reproduce. This recipe is written specifically for a high-temperature pizza oven such as a Gozney Roccbox or similar — attempting it in a conventional oven will not give the same result.

Low moisture mozzarella: pre-sliced squares of mozzarella from the supermarket are a good substitute in the UK, where blocks can be harder to find. Cut into small squares instead of grating — the result is just as good.

Pepperoni: a good quality pepperoni such as Properoni brand will crisp up at the edges in the oven rather than turning greasy and limp.

Hot honey: see the hot honey recipe for how to make your own.

Suggestions